Three Questions to Leading House Alumnus Dr. Jens Mohrenweiser
Question No. 1: What was your dissertation subject?
My PhD thesis analysed why firms train apprentices. It basically investigated two motives: the investment and substitution motive. The investment motive means that firms heavily invest in apprenticeship training. They typically keep their apprentices afterwards and offer them career and development opportunities. On the contrary, the substitution motive means that firms substitute low-skilled employees with apprentices who strongly contribute to productivity during apprenticeship. These firms balance training and working during apprenticeship and firms do not rely on keeping their apprenticeship graduates. Both motives are bound to specific occupations, i.e. there are “investment-motive-occupations” and “substitution-motive-occupations”.
My thesis further shows that apprentices who leave the training firm after apprenticeship typically get a wage penalty in investment motive occupations while such a stigma effect is not visible in substitution motive occupations.
Finally, my thesis showed that - unlike classical human capital theory may predict - non-training firms in Germany do not use a systematic poaching strategy to hire apprenticeship graduates.
Question No. 2: What is the main conclusion of your research for practice and/or for future Research?
I think my PhD thesis gives some important insights for countries that want to adopt an apprenticeship training system. In these countries, the threat of poaching is usually one of the main reasons why firms shy away from apprenticeship training. My PhD thesis has shown that poaching is not relevant for the substitution training motive, when firms already get their return during training via the contribution of apprentices to productivity. This is, for instance, quite relevant in the UK at the moment, where the government introduced an apprenticeship levy in April 2017 to boost apprenticeships. Let’s take a closer look at the hospitality sector in which the substitution motive predominates in traditional apprenticeship countries. Currently, low-skilled workers remain in a job for 4-6 months which limits the possibility of initial training in the sector and resulted in a call for skill shortage. Apprenticeships can address the skill shortage because they last for around one year in the hospitality sector. Apprenticeships give firms and apprentices a clear timeframe that allows firms to invest more in training for apprentices than currently for low skilled workers while getting the returns in form of higher productivity already during training. I believe the substitution training motive might be a much more powerful motive to convince firms to participate in apprenticeships. Reasonably designed, apprenticeships can be a win-win-win situation for firms, apprentices and the state.
Moreover, my PhD thesis has shown that poaching is not a huge problem in the investment motive either because leaving the training firm immediately after training can result in a lower wage than staying for some time. I showed in a paper of my PostDoc phase that this is due to the fact that apprenticeship certificates entail only grades about hard skills but not about soft skills. The information advantage about soft-skills gives training firms the possibility to counter outside offers for brilliant apprentices but they might think twice to do this for less good ones. Hence, apprentices leaving the training firm immediately after training in investment occupations are less likely to be seen as high performers.
Question No. 3: If you could choose one research finding in the field of education economics that changed the way you look at things, what would it be?
It not always matters what you can do, but what you believe you can do and what others believe you can do. These effects are remarkable strong for education attainment and labour market outcomes after education.
More news
- New PhD Student joins Leading House Team Zurich
- Aus der Forschung für die Praxis: Inside Berufsbildung Podcast mit Patricia Palffy
- Stellenangebot Doktorierende*r in „Betriebswirtschaftslehre“ oder „Management and Economics“ (70%)
- The Leading House welcomes three new Assistant Professors
- DigiKompetenz Podcast mit Prof. Uschi Backes-Gellner
- "Stepping up" - Review of the event with honorary doctor Prof. Eric P. Bettinger
- "Stepping up – Intergenerational Mobility and Identifying New Pools of Talent" - Event on 22.9.2022
- Promotionsfeier der Wirtschaftswissenschaftlichen Fakultät der Universität Zürich – Damiano Pregaldini für den SDG Impact Award nominiert
- Erste Internationale Konferenz in Berufsbildungsökonomie
- First International Conference on the Economics of Vocational Education and Training
- New Postdoc joins Leading House Team Zurich
- Leading House Best Paper Award 2021
- Guest Lecture Prof. Dr. Kerstin Pull, Inge Strauch Visiting Professor
- New PhD student joins Leading House Team Bern
- New PhD student joins Leading House Team Zurich
- New PhD student joins Leading House Team Bern
- Fabienne Kiener successfully defended her dissertation. Congratulations!
- Wie berufsspezifisch sollte die Berufsbildung sein?
- Inauguration ceremony for the new “Swiss Leading House VPET-ECON”
- Feierliche Eröffnung des neuen «Swiss Leading House VPET-ECON»
- Tobias Schultheiss successfully defended his dissertation. Congratulations!
- Our Team in Bern is looking for two PhD Positions in VPET Economics (80%)
- Apply now for the Course Program for Doctoral Students in Economics of Education
- New PhD student joins Leading House Team Zurich
- Neues «Leading House» wird auf bewährtem Fundament errichtet
- New "Leading House" established, building on solid foundation of previous work
- Im Umfeld von Fachhochschulen gedeihen Innovationen
- Damiano Pregaldini successfully defended his doctoral thesis. Congratulations!
- Ehrenpromotion für Prof. Uschi Backes-Gellner
- Tobias Schlegel successfully defended his doctoral thesis. Congratulations!
- Stefan Wolter Keynote Speaker at the 7th Congress on Research in VET
- Leading House Best Paper Award 2020
- Stefan C. Wolter elected to two new mandates
- Professor Edward P. Lazear has passed away
- Panel on “The Future of VET” organized by the World Bank
- Published in the "NZZ" on October 1st, 2020: "Everything better without examinations?"
- New Book on the Economics and Governance of Vocational and Professional Education and Training
- Patrick Lehnert successfully defended his doctoral thesis. Congratulations!
- Leading House Best Paper Award 2019
- The Impact of the COVID-19 crisis on the provision of apprenticeship in Switzerland
- Marco Pereira wins «UZH-2019 Fall Semester Prize» for his bachelor thesis
- Cancellation of Leading House Lecture of March 24th!
- 18th Leading House Lecture on Economics of Education held by Prof. Paul Osterman, MIT Sloan School of Management
- Prof. Backes-Gellner Mitglied im neu etablierten "Rat der Arbeitswelt" in Deutschland
- New paper on transitions after layoffs and the role of occupational skills
- Christian Eggenberger successfully defended his doctoral thesis. Congratulations!
- Studie zum Beitrag der Schweizer Berufsbildung zu Innovation
- Katharina Jaik successfully defended her doctoral thesis. Congratulations!
- New doctoral student joins Leading House Team Zurich
- Leading House Best Paper Award 2018
- Call for Papers: The Economics of Vocational Education and Training
- Apply now for the doctoral programme in economics of education
- Future Options for an Apprenticeship System in Colorado (USA)
- Panel discussion: What can the US learn from VET in Europe?
- Is apprenticeship training a cost-effective model for firms in Italy?
- Now open: Nomination for the «Prize for the best Dissertation in the Economics of Education 2017/2018»
- Leading House Best Paper Award 2017
- Jason Blunier wins «UZH-2017 Fall Semester Prize» for his bachelor thesis
- Apprenticeship training in England - a cost-effective model for firms?
- Digitisation and its consequences for employment in Switzerland
- Fachhochschulen und Innovation
- Three Questions to Leading House Alumnus Prof. Dr. Stephan Nüesch
- Peter Hoeschler successfully defended his doctoral thesis. Congratulations!
- Schmeller Price awarded to Luca Moretti
- Christa Pálffy successfully finished the “Berufsbildnerkurs” (Certificate for Vocational Trainer)
- Prof. Backes-Gellner again among “Top 100 Women in Business in Switzerland”
- Keynote Speech of Prof. Wolter on STEM and Gender
- New PhD student (Tobias Schlegel) joins Leading House Team Zurich
- Three Questions to LH Alumna Maria Olivares
- Curdin Pfister has successfully defended his dissertation
- New PhD student joins Leading House Team Zurich
- Prof. Backes-Gellner participates in the “Day of the Economy 2017” organized by economiesuisse
- Three Questions to LH Alumna Dr. Silvia Teuber
- Leading House cooperates for the third time with KOF/ETHZ on “Summer Institute for International Educational Reform Leaders”
- Three Questions to LH Alumna Mirjam Strupler Leiser
- Leading House members participate in Bike to Work 2017
- Three Questions to LH Alumnus Maximilian Wolf, Professor for Corporate Management and Human Resources at the University of Applied Sciences Albstadt-Sigmaringen
- Prof. Backes-Gellner gave Lead Lecture at University of Tübingen
- Three Questions to Leading House Alumnus Dr. Jan Sauermann
- Leading House Best Paper Award 2016
- New PhD student joins our team
- Winner of the UZH Annual Dissertation Award 2017 of University of Zurich: Miriam Rinawi
- New Special Issue on "Personnel Economics and VET" in Evidence-based HRM
- Three Questions to Leading House Alumnus Dr. Simon Janssen
- Best Paper Award of the 5th Congress on Research in VET
- Prof. Dr. Wolter elected Chairman of the Committee of Economics of Education
- Three Questions to Leading House Alumni Prof. Dr. Samuel Mühlemann
- Interview with Prof. Backes-Gellner in "Perspektiven der Wirtschaftspolitik"
- January Newsletter of the SERI is online
- 15th Leading House Lecture on Economics of Education held by Prof. Bernd Fitzenberger on “Additional Career Assistance and Educational Outcomes for Students in Lower Track Secondary Schools“
- Interview with Prof. Backes-Gellner on educational curricula and digitalization
- Just three weeks away from the COPE 2017
- CEMETS Blog – KOF EELI
- LH Paper choosen for Papers and Proceedings issue of American Economic Review
- Ten successful years for the Leading House Economics of Education are coming to an end
- Swiss professionals swept 6 medals at EuroSkills 2016 in Gothenburg
- Contracts for another funding phase of the Leading House on Economics of Education have been signed
- December Newsletter of the SERI is online
- Prof. Dr. Uschi Backes-Gellner member of the National Research Council of the Swiss National Science Foundation (SNSF)
- Alumni-Networking-Event marks 10-year anniversary of the Swiss Leading House on Economics of Education, Firm Behaviour and Training Policies!
- 14th Leading House Lecture on Economics of Education held by Prof. Thomas Dohmen on “Patience and the Wealth of Nations“
- Wall Street Journal cites research by Miriam Rinawi and Prof. Uschi Backes-Gellner
- Leading House cooperates for the second time with KOF/ETHZ on “Summer Institute for International Educational Reform Leaders”
- Published in the "NZZ" on June 29th, 2016: "An Apprenticeship Training System Needs no Subsidies"
- Call for Papers "20th Colloquium on Personnel Economics February 1st - 3rd, 2017, University of Zurich"
- Leading House Best Paper Award 2015
- Keynote on international developments in vocational education and training in Toronto
- Prof. Dr. Wolter referiert in Kanada zu Kosten und Nutzen der Berufsbildung für Unternehmen
- Prof. Dr. Wolter speaks in Cambridge and Ottawa
- 13th Leading House Lecture on Economics of Education held by Prof. David Marsden on „Teachers' reactions to performance pay in England and Wales"
- 12th Leading House Lecture on Economics of Education held by Stuart W. Elliott on „Computers and the Future of Skills and Productivity"
- Public Opinion on the financing of the Swiss educational system
- Applying the Swiss model of apprenticeship training to Chicago
- Dual education system at the German-Spanish Forum
- Keynote Speech at „The Economics of VET“ Conference in Bonn
- Keynote Speech at the "Pathways to Prosperity Network"
- Costs and benefits of apprenticeship training for Spanish firms
- What is the public's opinion?
- Published in the "Sonntagsblick" on August 9th, 2015: "Which class-size offers the best learning environment?"
- Call for Papers "19th Colloquium on Personnel Economics March 9th to 11th, 2016, RWTH Aachen University"
- Leading House cooperates with KOF/ETHZ on “Summer Institute for International Educational Reform Leaders”
- Leading House Best Paper Award 2014
- New research centre for vocational education at LSE
- Lohnunterschiede zwischen Männern und Frauen sind dort höher wo Gleichberechtigung klein geschrieben wird
- Prof. Dr. Stefan Wolter gives "Skyline lecture" about PISA data
- Prof. Dr. Stefan Wolter holds workshop on apprenticeship training in Spain
- Expertenkommission Forschung und Innovation legt Jahresgutachten vor
- Prof. Dr. Backes-Gellner presents research on vocational education in US-Congress
- Prof. Dr. Stefan Wolter speaks about dual apprenticeship training in Barcelona
- Prof. Dr. Stefan Wolter bietet neu den Masterkurs „Bildungsökonomie“ in Basel an
- Prof. Dr. Backes-Gellner New Vice Chairwoman of the Verein für Socialpolitik
- Prof. Dr. Stefan Wolter referiert im österreichischen Parlament
- Professor Dr. Edward Paul Lazear (Stanford University) to offer discussion workshop on Personnel economics and economics of education